Go Back
  • For Business
  • |
  • Warnings
  • Data Suite
  • Forensics
  • Advertising
  • Superior Accuracy™

Columbus, OH

54°F
Location Chevron down
Location News Videos
Use Current Location
Recent

Columbus

Ohio

54°
No results found.
Try searching for a city, zip code or point of interest.
settings
Columbus, OH Weather
Today WinterCast Local {stormName} Tracker Hourly Daily Radar MinuteCast® Monthly Air Quality Health & Activities

Around the Globe

Hurricane Tracker

Severe Weather

Radar & Maps

News

News & Features

Astronomy

Business

Climate

Health

Recreation

Sports

Travel

For Business

Warnings

Data Suite

Forensics

Advertising

Superior Accuracy™

Video

Winter Center

AccuWeather Early Hurricane Center Top Stories Trending Today Astronomy Heat Climate Health Recreation In Memoriam Case Studies Blogs & Webinars

News / Recreation

‘Our dreams were falling down the mountain’: American and British climbers stranded in the Himalayas for three days

A falling rock sliced through the rope carrying a climber's bag, leaving two climbers stranded in the Himalayas without vital supplies including their tent, stove, food, crampons and ice axes.

By Jessie Yeung and Esha Mitra, CNN

Published Oct 11, 2024 11:18 AM EDT | Updated Oct 11, 2024 12:06 PM EDT

Copied

Climbers Fay Manners and Michelle Dvorak attempted to summit Chaukhamba III in Uttarakhand, India, before they were stranded for three days. (Photo credit: Fay Manners via CNN Newsource)

(CNN) — Fay Manners and Michelle Dvorak were perched high on the snowy face of a Himalayan mountain when disaster struck their quest to become the first to summit its peak.

At more than 6,000 meters (about 20,000 feet) above sea level, a falling rock sliced through the rope carrying Manners’ bag, leaving the climbers stranded in the inhospitable wilderness without vital supplies including their tent, stove, food, crampons and ice axes.

“It was kind of a horrifying experience,” Manners told CNN on Wednesday from the Indian capital New Delhi, where the two women are now waiting to go home following their miraculous rescue.

“All I can really remember is just seeing the bag go down the mountain and being really shocked, thinking, ‘How has this happened? Like, what’s going on?’”

But for both climbers, their immediate reaction wasn’t fear for their safety or survival – it was devastation that their mission, which required painstaking preparation, training, and altitude acclimatization, was being cut short when they were so close to their goal.

Manners, a Briton living in France, and Dvorak, an American, had been “absolutely desperate” to reach the summit of the unclimbed peak in India’s northern Uttarakhand state.

The two climbers were aiming to be the first to summit Chaukhamba III in the Himalayas. (Photo credit Fay Manners via CNN Newsorce)

Their attempt to climb the nearly 7,000-meter Chaukhamba III began on September 27, as they clambered across ice and rock and slept on narrow ledges. The approach to the mountain alone was incredibly tough, Manners said – they had chosen a maze-like route that navigated endless deep crevasses and precarious snow bridges that risked collapsing in warmer weather. It took three attempts before they could even reach the base of the mountain, she said.

“We were near the end of all the difficulties … (we) maybe had one more day to get to the summit, and then we would have been the first to reach this summit,” Manners said. Instead, “our dreams were just falling down the mountain.”

The bag they lost contained vital supplies including their tent, stove, food, and Manners' crampons and ice axes. (Photo credit: Fay Manners via CNN Newsource)

Without their gear, climbing back down and across the crevasses was near-impossible, so they contacted emergency services for help. But the severity of their situation soon became clear when helicopters failed to spot them on the vast mountain face the next morning – and again the following day.

Ravindra Singh Negi, the information officer in Uttarakhand’s Chamoli district, told CNN the rescue operation had included the Indian Air Force, the State Disaster Response Force and the Nehru Institute of Mountaineering.

“We searched all day at the coordinates provided to us by the tour company but did not find anything,” he said.

All the while, the climbers had no food besides two energy bars that they “nibbled on,” and no water, since their stove to melt snow had been lost, Manners said.

Even their dehydrated food was no use without the stove. At one point, desperate and dehydrated, they abseiled to a spot with dripping ice and collected a tiny amount of water during the few hours when the sun was out.

And the conditions steadily deteriorated as they faced a snowstorm, hail and even an avalanche. They huddled together in their wet sleeping bag, hair frozen solid, with nighttime temperatures reaching –15 degrees Celsius (5 degrees Fahrenheit).

“I was close to hypothermia, I think, and I was shaking so violently through the night that Michelle had to hold my legs to just try and keep me warm,” Manners said. “That sleeping bag saved our lives.”

That’s when they knew they had to act, even if they were weak and disoriented, she said. The next morning, they began abseiling down the mountain through thick fog, knowing the journey back to base camp could be “incredibly dangerous” with high chances of serious injury or falling down a crevasse.

They spent three days waiting for rescue before venturing down the mountain by themselves, until they were found by a French climbing team. (Photo credit: Fay Manners via CNN Newsource)

But as they reached the bottom, they glimpsed a group of French mountaineers – a rival team that had also been hoping to reach the summit first. Negi, the information officer, said Indian authorities had reached out to the French team for assistance after being unable to locate Manners and Dvorak.

When Manners realized the French team had been sent to rescue them, “all my emotions came out at once, and I had some tears in my eyes,” she said.

With their help, she and Dvorak trekked to the French base camp, munching on cheese their rescuers had brought from France, she said. The Indian Air Force then airlifted them to a nearby hospital on Sunday, three long days after they were stranded.

A photo released by the Indian Air Force showing the rescue of the climbers, who were airlifted to a hospital in Joshimath, Uttarakhand, for assessment. (Photo credit: Indian Air Force/X (formerly Twitter) via CNN Newsource)

Both climbers are uninjured and eager to fly home. And their brush with death hasn’t deterred them from following their dreams, said Manners, who encourages women and girls to pursue the sport. She wants to try the summit again next year – perhaps with the French team who rescued them.

When people look at their experience, she hopes they see two strong women who “got really close to the top,” she said. And when things went awry, they were “still able to survive and manage themselves through that really adverse and terrible situation.”

Read more:

Five Russian climbers die on Nepal’s Dhaulagiri mountain
Climber dies from fall off Wyoming's Devils Tower
Missing Washington hiker rescued a month after going missing ‘may have only had another day left’ alive, rescuer says

The-CNN-Wire™ & © 2024 Cable News Network, Inc., a Warner Bros. Discovery Company. All rights reserved.

Report a Typo

Weather News

video

Early Utah snowfall covers red rocks in white

Oct. 18, 2025
video

Tornado fears, preparedness gap: What Americans worry about most

Oct. 16, 2025
video

Southeast thunderstorms produce torrential rain, lightning

Oct. 19, 2025
Show more Show less Chevron down

Topics

AccuWeather Early

Hurricane Center

Top Stories

Trending Today

Astronomy

Heat

Climate

Health

Recreation

In Memoriam

Case Studies

Blogs & Webinars

Top Stories

Severe Weather

Fall storm to march east, bringing damaging winds

1 hour ago

Weather Forecasts

Atmospheric River to advance into the West Coast this week

2 hours ago

Astronomy

Orionids to peak Monday night with up to 20 meteors per hour

22 hours ago

Hurricane

Caribbean tropical threat may develop this week

1 hour ago

Weather Forecasts

Drought lowering Mississippi River levels again, disrupting shipping

22 hours ago

More Stories

Featured Stories

Travel

Two killed as cargo plane skids off runway into the sea in Hong Kong

1 hour ago

Weather News

Polar bears take over abandoned island in Russia

1 hour ago

AccuWeather Ready

Daylight Saving Time: 5 things to do after changing the clocks

4 days ago

Recreation

Runner wrestles bear in Japanese woods: ‘In one bite my arm was done’

1 hour ago

Astronomy

Sunlight on demand: the satellites that could brighten our nights

15 minutes ago

AccuWeather Recreation ‘Our dreams were falling down the mountain’: American and British climbers stranded in the Himalayas for three days
Company
Proven Superior Accuracy™ About AccuWeather Digital Advertising Careers Press Contact Us
Products & Services
For Business For Partners For Advertising AccuWeather APIs AccuWeather Connect RealFeel® and RealFeel Shade™ Personal Weather Stations
Apps & Downloads
iPhone App Android App See all Apps & Downloads
Subscription Services
AccuWeather Premium AccuWeather Professional
More
AccuWeather Ready Business Health Hurricane Leisure and Recreation Severe Weather Space and Astronomy Sports Travel Weather News Winter Center
Company
Proven Superior Accuracy™ About AccuWeather Digital Advertising Careers Press Contact Us
Products & Services
For Business For Partners For Advertising AccuWeather APIs AccuWeather Connect RealFeel® and RealFeel Shade™ Personal Weather Stations
Apps & Downloads
iPhone App Android App See all Apps & Downloads
Subscription Services
AccuWeather Premium AccuWeather Professional
More
AccuWeather Ready Business Health Hurricane Leisure and Recreation Severe Weather Space and Astronomy Sports Travel Weather News Winter Center
© 2025 AccuWeather, Inc. "AccuWeather" and sun design are registered trademarks of AccuWeather, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | About Your Privacy Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information | Data Sources

...

...

...