Nor’easter exposes likely 1884 shipwreck on Nantucket
Gale-force winds wrecked the Warren Sawyer on Nantucket’s south shore 142 years ago. This weekend’s storm stripped away enough sand to expose what appears to be part of it.
A powerful nor’easter has uncovered what appears to be a piece of a wooden schooner that ran aground on Nantucket’s south shore nearly 142 years ago.
The storm stripped sand from a bluff near the drive-on beach access at Point of Breakers, exposing a large section of shipwreck. Winds reached 49 mph on Nantucket, with a peak gust of 64 mph at Nantucket Memorial Airport, according to National Weather Service observations.
The storm also dropped at least 2.4 inches of rain over 48 hours, while wind-driven surf stripped sand from the island’s south shore and exposed the wreckage. Big surf and erosion reshaped sections of the south shore, while minor flooding affected familiar waterfront trouble spots.
Nantucket resident David DeHart first spotted the timbers Saturday and alerted Jason Graziadei, editor-in-chief of the Nantucket Current.
“I drove out there with my son Owen and sure enough, it was right there where David said it was,” Graziadei told NPR.
Wreckage could be from 1884 Warren Sawyer schooner
The wreckage is in the same location where wooden fragments surfaced in 2022 and early 2023. After studying archival, photographic and archaeological evidence, researchers concluded those pieces most likely came from the Warren Sawyer, a three-masted schooner wrecked near Miacomet Beach on Dec. 22, 1884.
David Robinson, director and chief archaeologist for the Massachusetts Board of Underwater Archaeological Resources, said photos and video of the new find point to the same conclusion.
“It’s in the same place,” Robinson told the Current. “The logical conclusion” is that it is the same wreckage identified in 2022.
The Warren Sawyer was sailing from New Orleans to Boston with 1,115 bales of cotton and 28 tons of scrap iron when gale-force winds blew it off course and drove it ashore around 11 p.m. The vessel rolled violently in the surf, but Captain Edwin L. Saunders and his seven crew members were rescued within an hour by the Surfside Lifesaving Station.
By the time the sea was finished with the Warren Sawyer, only part of its bow remained on the beach to mark where the cargo schooner had run aground. A Jan. 10, 1885, account in Nantucket’s Inquirer and Mirror captured the ship’s final hours: “With a sharp crash, a large portion of the weather quarter gives way before the blow of huge seas.”
When the schooner’s lifeboat was smashed in the surf, the crew climbed into the mizzen rigging as waves engulfed the deck. On shore, Surfside Lifesaving Station patrolman Eugene Clisby spotted the ship’s lights and called for help.
Rescuers eventually got a line to the schooner, rigged a breeches buoy and brought Captain Edwin L. Saunders and his seven crew members safely to the beach by midnight, according to the Inquirer and Mirror’s account of the wreck.
For the next two weeks, salvage crews used ox teams, skids and the island railroad to haul cotton bales from the wreck. Curious residents rode trains to the south shore to watch the disaster unfold until another storm broke the schooner apart and scattered what remained along the beach.
The newly exposed timbers have not been examined in person, and the Maria Mitchell Association said more investigation is needed. But 142 years after wind and surf sent the Warren Sawyer ashore, another storm has pulled what may be part of it back into view.
Report a Typo