Trump shrinks Bears Ears, Grand Staircase-Escalante in largest cutback of protected land in American history
By Emma Curtis , AccuWeather staff writer
December 05, 2017, 9:06:32 AM EST
Share this article:
President Trump reduced the occupied area of two Utah national monuments by more than 2 million acres on Monday.
The shrinking of Bears Ears by 85 percent and Grand Staircase-Esclante by half marks the largest cutback of protected land in American history.
Grand Staircase-Escalante was marked a national monument by President Clinton in 1996 and Bears Ears was designated by President Obama just last year. Trump’s move comes with a push for fewer restrictions and more development on protected land throughout the country.
President Donald Trump holds up a signed proclamation to shrink the size of Bears Ears and Grand Staircase Escalante national monuments at the Utah State Capitol Monday, Dec. 4, 2017, in Salt Lake City. (AP Photo/Rick Bowmer)
The move to shrink the monuments may be the beginning of a long battle against the precedents set by the 1906 Antiquities Act.
The act states that a monument must be the “smallest area compatible” with protecting any historical or scientific significance that prompted protection of the land. Many have argued that the protection of both Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante were much bigger than necessary. Bears Ears was designated more than 1.3 million acres.
RELATED:
Trump's move to scale back two national monuments in Utah sparks backlash
Utah protesters call for Trump to preserve national monuments
Trump wants to shrink two national monuments in Utah
Trump argued that his decision to decrease the land size goes hand in hand with the Antiquity Act’s requirement that the region remains the “smallest area compatible.” He stated that areas of the original monument “are not unique” or are "not of significant scientific or historic interest.”
Under Trump’s proclamation, Bears Ears will shrink to just over 200,000 acres while keeping the celebrated and recognized features of the region like Bears Ears, Doll House Ruins, Mule Canyon and Comb Ridge protected.
Utah Senator and President pro tempore of the United States Senate Orrin Hatch and Utah Senator Mike Lee each released a statement on Twitter in favor of the administration’s decision to reduce the size of the monuments.
Hatch on President @realDonaldTrump’s Monument proclamation. #utpol pic.twitter.com/RljtEqKsCL
— Senator Hatch Office (@senorrinhatch) December 4, 2017
President Trump did the people of Utah a great favor today by rolling back harmful land use restrictions in southern Utah. #utpol pic.twitter.com/RZFJd0K6pi
— Mike Lee (@SenMikeLee) December 4, 2017
However, the decision was also met with waves of criticism. Navajo Nation, house democrats and sustainable clothing company, Patagonia, have each released a statement condemning the President’s choice to reduce the protected land so drastically.
The Navajo Nation has released a statement on Donald Trump's Bears Ears decision #copolitics pic.twitter.com/Ff9PDgZa0z
— Jesse Aaron Paul (@JesseAPaul) December 4, 2017
#BREAKING: @POTUS signed a proclamation to dramatically scale back 2 Utah nat'l monuments.
— Nat Resources Dems (@NRDems) December 4, 2017
"Trump seems to take a perverse joy in ignoring fed law & dismissing the wishes of #NativeAmerican tribes, conservation leaders & millions of Americans" @RepRaulGrijalva #MonumentsForAll
This is the largest elimination of protected land in American history.
— Patagonia (@patagonia) December 4, 2017
Take Action: https://t.co/biZPxo7PHh#BearsEars pic.twitter.com/OqW9FHPk3Q
Many opponents of the decision feel that Trump is using overarching powers for economic gain without considering the impacts of conservation.
Some of those in favor argue that the most important areas will still remained protected and the reduction of size creates endless opportunities for economic improvement.
Various organizations seek to sue President Trump over his decision. One lawsuit, comprised of The Wilderness Society, the Natural Resources Defense Council and the Sierra Club argues that Trump's decision to reduce the size of Grand Staircase-Escalante was "unlawful" and "exceeds his authority under the US Constitution and the Antiquities Act."
BREAKING: President Trump made his announcement & we are gearing up for a legal battle to #StandWithBearsEars & #SaveGrandStaircase https://t.co/Px2Rbm1RgW pic.twitter.com/vaYdEqInQC
— Wilderness Society (@Wilderness) December 4, 2017
A coalition of five American Indian tribes was the first to file a lawsuit against the proclamation.
More Weather News
-
'Don’t feed the fatberg,' what are fatbergs and how do they form?
Weather News - January 16, 2019, 2:21:22 PM EST
A fatberg forms like a snowball, as wet wipes, as well as fats, oil and grease congeal together in the sewer. When this mass gets large enough, the fatberg can clog sewers entirely.
-
Venus-Jupiter conjunction: Set your alarm for this celestial meet-up on Tuesday morning
Weather News - January 16, 2019, 3:38:04 PM EST
Jupiter and Venus will shine bright together before dawn on Tuesday in an astronomical event known as a conjunction.
-
Cold air, snow to descend on the UK in the coming days
Weather News - January 16, 2019, 11:58:55 AM EST
The arrival of much colder air across the United Kingdom will set the stage for some areas to have their first snowfall of the year on Friday.
-
Super Blood Moon Lunar Eclipse to dazzle South America on Sunday night
Weather News - January 16, 2019, 11:30:09 AM EST
A total solar eclipse will be seen across the entirety of South America on Sunday night, marking the final such occurrence of this decade.
-
What are ice disks?
Weather News
The mesmerizing frozen formations are natural phenomena that are fairly common in the colder climates of North America.
-
Blockbuster storm to bring heavy snow, ice and fierce winds in northeastern US this weekend
Weather News - January 16, 2019, 3:42:36 PM EST
The second of two storms this week will be a blockbuster in terms of impact with a foot or more of snow forecast to fall from northern Pennsylvania to upstate New York and northern New England this weekend.
-
Bad air pollution linked to increased psychological distress
Weather News - January 16, 2019, 9:43:54 AM EST
Air pollution is the fourth-largest threat to human health, behind high blood pressure, dietary risks and smoking, and it has been linked to mental distress as well.
-
3.7 magnitude earthquake shakes Piedmont, California
Weather News - January 16, 2019, 9:01:50 AM EST
A 3.7 preliminary magnitude earthquake struck Piedmont, California, early Wednesday morning. Two aftershocks of 2.0 and 1.9 magnitudes have also struck the region.
-
'Don’t feed the fatberg,' what are fatbergs and how do they form?
Weather News - January 16, 2019, 2:21:22 PM EST
A fatberg forms like a snowball, as wet wipes, as well as fats, oil and grease congeal together in the sewer. When this mass gets large enough, the fatberg can clog sewers entirely.
-
Venus-Jupiter conjunction: Set your alarm for this celestial meet-up on Tuesday morning
Weather News - January 16, 2019, 3:38:04 PM EST
Jupiter and Venus will shine bright together before dawn on Tuesday in an astronomical event known as a conjunction.
-
Cold air, snow to descend on the UK in the coming days
Weather News - January 16, 2019, 11:58:55 AM EST
The arrival of much colder air across the United Kingdom will set the stage for some areas to have their first snowfall of the year on Friday.
-
Super Blood Moon Lunar Eclipse to dazzle South America on Sunday night
Weather News - January 16, 2019, 11:30:09 AM EST
A total solar eclipse will be seen across the entirety of South America on Sunday night, marking the final such occurrence of this decade.
-
What are ice disks?
Weather News
The mesmerizing frozen formations are natural phenomena that are fairly common in the colder climates of North America.
-
Blockbuster storm to bring heavy snow, ice and fierce winds in northeastern US this weekend
Weather News - January 16, 2019, 3:42:36 PM EST
The second of two storms this week will be a blockbuster in terms of impact with a foot or more of snow forecast to fall from northern Pennsylvania to upstate New York and northern New England this weekend.
-
Bad air pollution linked to increased psychological distress
Weather News - January 16, 2019, 9:43:54 AM EST
Air pollution is the fourth-largest threat to human health, behind high blood pressure, dietary risks and smoking, and it has been linked to mental distress as well.
-
3.7 magnitude earthquake shakes Piedmont, California
Weather News - January 16, 2019, 9:01:50 AM EST
A 3.7 preliminary magnitude earthquake struck Piedmont, California, early Wednesday morning. Two aftershocks of 2.0 and 1.9 magnitudes have also struck the region.
TRENDING NOW
Sunday's AFC championship game between Chiefs, Patriots could be coldest on record in Arrowhead Stadium
Sunday is shaping up to be brutally cold in Kansas City as fans fill Arrowhead Stadium to watch the AFC championship game.
Read Story
What are ice disks?
The mesmerizing frozen formations are natural phenomena that are fairly common in the colder climates of North America.
Read Story
Comments
Comments that don't add to the conversation may be automatically or manually removed by Facebook or AccuWeather. Profanity, personal attacks, and spam will not be tolerated.