Go Back
  • For Business
  • |
  • Warnings
  • Data Suite
  • Forensics
  • Advertising
  • Superior Accuracy™
Flash flood dangers far from over as storms reload across US. Details here Chevron right
Tropical rainstorm soaks Florida, could strengthen in Gulf before targeting Louisiana Chevron right

Ashburn, VA

83°F
Location Chevron down
Location News Videos
Use Current Location
Recent

Ashburn

Virginia

83°
No results found.
Try searching for a city, zip code or point of interest.
settings
Ashburn, VA Weather
Today WinterCast Local {stormName} Tracker Hourly Daily Radar MinuteCast Monthly Air Quality Health & Activities

Around the Globe

Hurricane Tracker

Severe Weather

Radar & Maps

News

News & Features

Astronomy

Business

Climate

Health

Recreation

Sports

Travel

For Business

Warnings

Data Suite

Forensics

Advertising

Superior Accuracy™

Video

Winter Center

AccuWeather Early Hurricane Center Top Stories Trending Today Astronomy Heat Climate Health Recreation In Memoriam Case Studies Blogs & Webinars

News / Weather News

A showdown over Colorado River water is setting the stage for a high-stakes legal battle

The federal government wanted seven western states that rely on the river to decide how to cut up to 30% of its water allocation. But there's one holdout: California.

By Ella Nilsen, CNN

Published Jan 31, 2023 1:13 PM EDT | Updated Jan 31, 2023 1:13 PM EDT

Copied

The Colorado River is seen here from atop the historic Navajo Bridge in Arizona on Jan. 1, 2023. (RJ Sangosti/The Denver Post/Getty Images)

(CNN) -- Months of bitter negotiations between seven states that rely on the Colorado River's vanishing water have collapsed along a clear fault line over the past week: California versus everyone else.

The multi-state talks, which have been ongoing in fits and starts for months, were focused on achieving unprecedented water cuts to save the Colorado River -- a system that provides water and electricity to more than 40 million people in the West.

As less and less water has been flowing through the river and its reservoirs, U.S. Bureau of Reclamation Commissioner Camille Touton last year called on the basin's seven states -- California, Arizona, Nevada, New Mexico, Colorado, Utah and Wyoming -- to figure out how to cut 2 to 4 million acre feet of usage, or as much as 30% of their river water allocation.

If they couldn't agree on how to do it, Touton vowed the federal government would step in.

On Monday, six states -- including lower basin states of Arizona and Nevada -- released a letter and a proposed model for how much Colorado River water they could potentially cut to stave off a collapse and prevent the nation's largest reservoirs, Lakes Mead and Powell, from hitting "dead pool," when water levels will be too low to flow through the dams.

The maximum amount of basin-wide cuts the six states are proposing in their model is 3.1 million acre feet per year. It accounts for water conservation and evaporation and, if approved, could kick in if reservoir levels fall to catastrophically low conditions.

California -- the largest user of Colorado River water -- is conspicuously absent from the text and will release its own letter and model calling for more modest annual cuts of around 1 million acre feet later this week, JB Hamby, the chair of the Colorado River Board for the state and an Imperial Irrigation District board member, told CNN.

Behind the rift is a decades-long, rancorous relationship between California and Arizona that has collided with a river system in crisis due to years of overuse and climate change-fueled drought.

People walk by a formerly sunken boat standing upright into the air with its stern buried in the mud along the shoreline of Lake Mead at the Lake Mead National Recreation Area, Friday, Jan. 27, 2023, near Boulder City, Nevada. (AP Photo/John Locher)

The split between California and the six other basin states raises the likelihood that the water battle could end up in the nation's highest courts, especially if the feds propose steep cuts for California and its powerful water districts believe their senior water rights are under threat. The Imperial Irrigation District provides water to Southern California farmers and has a senior right to Colorado River water -- a priority claim because it was established before other districts' and states' rights.

"The lack of a consensus and six states moving forward with an approach that does not harmonize with the law is troubling," Hamby said. "It is everyone's best interest to avoid litigation, but being put into a situation like this where you have six states approaching things in this way raises the risk."

In the meantime, one of the West's most important water sources will continue to dry up.

"I think California is playing with fire here," said David Hayes, a former top climate aide to President Joe Biden, now at Stanford University Law School. "This issue is bigger than any group of water rights holders. The implications of not addressing this issue could affect the economy of the entire state of California."

As state consensus proves difficult to reach and pressure grows on the federal government to act unilaterally, many negotiators and outside observers are expecting this year to bring litigation that could wind up at the Supreme Court.

"I don't know if the Supreme Court would take it," Wade Noble, a lawyer representing Yuma, Arizona, farmers and irrigation districts, told CNN. "I suspect everybody who has been lawyering up wants to make sure their legal team has Supreme Court experience. These are the types of issues that get there."

Priority vs. reality

The issue at the heart of why it has been so difficult for California and Arizona to agree on water cuts comes down to priority: Who is legally first in line for water when cuts occur.

Imperial Irrigation District's senior rights entitle it to use just over 3 million acre-feet of Colorado River water every year, the same amount of water as Arizona and Nevada's entire allocations combined.

The sun sets on the shrinking Lake Mead in April 2022, where water has declined to levels not seen since the reservoir was filled after the construction of Hoover Dam. (Caitlin Ochs/Reuters/FILE )

Arizona agreed to a junior water right in 1968, in exchange for building the Central Arizona Project -- a system of canals that divert Colorado River water to cities and agriculture from Phoenix to Tucson. That means historically, Arizona has been the first in line for cuts, while California's river allocation has been left untouched. Arizona has more recently argued that future cuts need to be spread around more evenly, rather than cities like Phoenix and Tuscon getting cut to zero.

"We need all water users to be able to look at the real situation on the river now," said Brenda Burman, general manager of the Central Arizona Project and a former Bureau of Reclamation commissioner in the Trump administration. "When you look at how this river has shrunk, when you look at how much less water there is in the river than any of us ever thought -- you have to say everyone who receives a benefit from this infrastructure needs to be willing to put some water on the table."

But the senior water right is one the Imperial Irrigation District plans to staunchly defend.

"We're not going to give up a century of history and position and things that people worked for over a century to protect in two days," Hamby said of the recent negotiations. "Doing away with the priority approach is not something that's acceptable."

Experts said that arguments of senior water users that they have the oldest right may run into the reality that the river system is crashing quickly.

"A hundred-year-old agreement is not necessarily going to be around for another 100 years and the whole system could get blown up," Hayes said.

Hayes added he fears possible future litigation could delay needed action on the river.

"Decisions to cut back water deliveries below the Hoover Dam cannot wait for a complex water rights case to be litigated up through the Supreme Court. That can take years," Hayes said. "Plus, no legal decision will solve the fundamental problem of insufficient water. That reality needs to be faced."

The-CNN-Wire™ & © 2023 Cable News Network, Inc., a Warner Bros. Discovery Company. All rights reserved.

READ MORE HERE:

LIVE: Death toll, power outages climb as ice storm continues
How Calif. floods could set the stage for a dangerous wildfire season
Bing! Stephen Tobolowsky relives “Groundhog Day”
Report a Typo

Weather News

Weather News

Inside the grueling recovery effort after Texas’ deadly flood

Jul. 15, 2025
Severe Weather

Flash flooding swamps Northeast metro areas as extreme rain threatens ...

Jul. 15, 2025
Weather Forecasts

Flood-weary Texas finally drying out, but near 100-degree heat looms

Jul. 16, 2025
Weather News

The Deadliest Floods in Texas History: A State at Risk

Jul. 14, 2025
video

Before-and-after pictures show devastation caused by Texas floods

Jul. 9, 2025
Severe Weather

Severe weather to rumble in the central US through the holiday weekend

Jul. 6, 2025
Weather News

Record sargassum seaweed piles up on Caribbean islands, Gulf

Jul. 2, 2025
Weather News

Alabama teen in ICU after lightning strike hits boat, causing burns an...

Jul. 2, 2025
Show more Show less Chevron down

Topics

AccuWeather Early

Hurricane Center

Top Stories

Trending Today

Astronomy

Heat

Climate

Health

Recreation

In Memoriam

Case Studies

Blogs & Webinars

Top Stories

Weather News

Inside the grueling recovery effort after Texas’ deadly flood

23 hours ago

Hurricane

Gulf tropical rainstorm to threaten Louisiana with flooding

21 minutes ago

Weather Forecasts

Flood-weary Texas finally drying out, but near 100-degree heat looms

6 hours ago

Weather News

Grand Canyon fires force closures

11 hours ago

Weather Forecasts

Flash flood dangers far from over as storms reload across US

18 minutes ago

More Stories

Featured Stories

Astronomy

Noctilucent clouds shimmer in summer sky

1 day ago

Recreation

Yellowstone’s landscape shifts again with discovery of new hot pool

1 day ago

Weather News

Orcas are bringing humans gifts of food – but why?

5 days ago

Weather News

Giant shoes found spark mystery around the soldiers of ancient Rome

1 day ago

Weather News

It’s not just humans – chimpanzees also like to follow trends

1 day ago

AccuWeather Weather News A showdown over Colorado River water is setting the stage for a high-stakes legal battle
Company
Proven Superior Accuracy About AccuWeather Digital Advertising Careers Press Contact Us
Products & Services
For Business For Partners For Advertising AccuWeather APIs AccuWeather Connect RealFeel® and RealFeel Shade™ Personal Weather Stations
Apps & Downloads
iPhone App Android App See all Apps & Downloads
Subscription Services
AccuWeather Premium AccuWeather Professional
More
AccuWeather Ready Business Health Hurricane Leisure and Recreation Severe Weather Space and Astronomy Sports Travel Weather News Winter Center
Company
Proven Superior Accuracy About AccuWeather Digital Advertising Careers Press Contact Us
Products & Services
For Business For Partners For Advertising AccuWeather APIs AccuWeather Connect RealFeel® and RealFeel Shade™ Personal Weather Stations
Apps & Downloads
iPhone App Android App See all Apps & Downloads
Subscription Services
AccuWeather Premium AccuWeather Professional
More
AccuWeather Ready Business Health Hurricane Leisure and Recreation Severe Weather Space and Astronomy Sports Travel Weather News Winter Center
© 2025 AccuWeather, Inc. "AccuWeather" and sun design are registered trademarks of AccuWeather, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | About Your Privacy Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information

...

...

...