GOVERNMENT TO BLAME FOR KATRINA FLOODING? HOW ABOUT BUILDING MUCH OF CITY NEAR OR BELOW SEA LEVEL SURROUNDED BY 86-DEGREE WATER?
The ruling that shoddy management by the Army Corp of engineers of a navigation channel seems to me to be a classic case of simply trying to find one cause for something that has multiple causes.
Here, look at this article.
Now let me, since it was on national TV on Friday p.m. before Katrina that I told people to get out of New Orleans, weigh in on this.
1) Katrina was not because of global warming. If you want to play that card, then explain why it weakened from a 5 to a 3 before landfall, something that may have happened multiple times in seasons like 1915-1916 as we didn't have constant recon then. So no global warming finger.
2) The city is lucky to be alive in the first place. Someone has got to say it, and out of respect for what happened there, I have kept my mouth shut except in talks I give, but face it, you build a city near or under sea level, and surround it with water that can support Category 3, 4 or 5 hurricanes, what do you expect to happen? The dirty little secret that no one wants to address but I will, is New Orleans was lucky. The attack by Katrina was not a full frontal assault, but a pincer movement that spared the city the prime devastation. Push water back west to the north of the city, then have the northwest wind blast it back in. However, if you get the track of the 1947 hurricane and it's as strong as Katrina, then the city would be devastated probably beyond repair. I don't know if people understand that. The track from the east-southeast hitting NORTH of the mouth of the Mississippi and moving right over the town would push the 20- to 30-foot surge, not 9-12 feet like Katrina, back through lakes Bourne and Pontchartrain with the full fury of the storm passing directly over the city.
3) The toughest thing to say, the populace itself. However, look how many of us are NOT awake to what is going on today in anything. We go about our daily lives and say, "well I can't do anything about that, so why try to find out what is really going on?" And this is the case there. I was in New Orleans in May 2005 and make no mistake about it, I LOVE NEW ORLEANS. In fact, The Howl at the Moon Piano Bar may be one of the most enjoyable places I have ever been at (the piano players play for tips, which are jacked up through the roof by people bidding on songs that have their state featured. So when Texans and Oklahomans go at it, a song will be played that will fetch a $100 tip, and then the opposing state will bid $105. It's fun to watch, but since we have state taxes in Pennsylvania, I never have bid). But upon moseying up to the bar for an adult beverage, I asked the bartender for the best local drink.. So he said, "that would be a hurricane." I said, "Will you give it to me New Orleans style?" He said, "You wouldn't like that, it would be too weak. We don't have strong hurricanes here in New Orleans."
Now you may say, how can you judge by that? But most of the people there did not understand what was going to happen with Katrina because they had forgotten Betsy, and Camille the Category 5 was not bad there. Even Lili, which the director of the hurricane center had said would be the strongest storm ever to hit Louisiana, and given their history, that would be like saying the Phillies would sweep the Yankees in four games, all of them shutouts, fell apart rapidly in the 12 hours before. So the mentality was such that people did not think this could be the problem that had people blasting me on blogs for causing panic it turned out to be. Part of that had to be with local officials, not the federal government, which I feel has been given a bum rap on this matter.
And of course that dove tails into the idea that putting faith OR BLAME on the government is not what living free is all about.
Now let's issue another ruling on the army corps of engineers. Since we are going to "blame" them for Katrina, let us also say that up until Katrina, they did a good enough job with that navigation channel to help bring more commerce to New Orleans.
But folks, and I pray I am wrong, you haven't seen what can happen to New Orleans in a worst case, which has happened twice on the Mississippi coast. And when, not if, it does, it's not global warming or poor management that does, but nature simply reminding man that she, not man, has the final say on issues of nature.
Thanks for reading. Ciao for now.